Illinois Governor Pat Quinn |
Governor Pat Quinn
Office of the Governor
207 State House
Springfield, Illinois 62706
Dear Governor Quinn:
I
watched your press conference last Friday where you announced sweeping pension
changes for active Illinois teachers.
These changes will hurt my family, and I object to them
strenuously. My daughter and
son-in-law are active teachers here in Sandwich, and
they have two children.
Your proposal to change the pension formula for active teachers will
cause them to pay more into the Teachers Retirement System and receive
less in benefits. This will not
only impact their ability to earn a living but will hurt my grandchildren as
well.
I
urge you to reconsider your proposal to change the pension system in Illinois,
and I offer you a number of clear reasons why you should change your mind.
First,
all active Illinois teachers have faithfully contributed 9.4%
of their salaries to TRS. The
State of Illinois has not met its contribution obligation. You are asking active teachers to bear
the brunt of the state legislature’s incompetence by raising the contribution
amount for active teachers to 12.4%.
This is grossly unfair!
Second,
raising the retirement age to 67 is discriminatory toward female teachers who
must take maternity leave to deliver and raise their children. Most of the women teachers in the state
use up their sick days when they have a baby, and then they must take more time
off without receiving credit for teaching. My wife, Pam was off from teaching for two years when she
had our child in 1977. Raising the
retirement age to 67 means that women teachers will have to teach well into
their seventies, Governor. I don’t
know about you, but I don’t want my great-grandchildren in a kindergarten class
taught by a seventy-year-old teacher!
Third,
reducing the Cost of Living Adjustment for active teachers when they retire
will force them to find other employment, and that is almost impossible after
age 67. I know, I’m 64 years old,
and I’ve been looking for a full-time job since I retired from teaching in 2007.
Remember,
Governor, teachers in Illinois do not receive Social Security benefits, and
your proposal to change the retirement formula will reduce active teachers’
take-home pay. Active teachers
like my daughter and son-in-law will not be able to contribute money to a
403(b) account to use as a back-up because they will have to cut their
household budget just to make ends meet.
Teachers in downstate communities like Sandwich do not make the same
salaries as teachers in suburbs like Palatine and Downers Grove. Downstate teachers will be impacted
much more negatively by your plan than will teachers in the wealthy suburbs.
Fourth, your proposal is unconstitutional. The Pension Clause of the 1970 Illinois Constitution provides:
Membership
in any pension or retirement system of the State, any unit
of local government or school district, or any agency or instrumentality
thereof, shall be an enforceable contractual relationship,
the benefits of which shall not be diminished or impaired.
(1970 Illinois Constitution, Article XIII, Section 5).
All active teachers entered into a contract with
the State of Illinois on the day they began teaching in the public
schools. You are proposing that
teachers’ benefits be “diminished,” which according to the above article from
the constitution, the state cannot do.
What
you are doing, Governor, is setting up a long court battle that will waste the
taxpayers’ money. I’m no lawyer,
but the provision above seems clear cut.
Your changes to the pension formula are unconstitutional.
Fifth,
most political pundits contend one of the main reasons for your election
victory in 2010 over Bill Brady was the support of Illinois teachers. Most of the experts thought that Brady
would be victorious. But teachers
flocked to the polls in droves to vote for you, Governor. I voted for you, my wife voted for you,
and my daughter and son-in-law voted for you. And this is the thanks we get for our support? If these changes you propose pass, you
will not receive my vote in 2014—that you can count on!
Sixth,
the Civic Committee of the Commercial Club of Chicago has poured thousands of
dollars into its “Illinois Is Still Broke” campaign. The Civic Committee is made up of wealthy business people
who pay much less of a percentage of their income in taxes than active teachers
do. Plus, you and the legislature
continue to give large corporations, such as Motorola, tax breaks. These taxes that Motorola and the
members of the Civic Committee are NOT paying could certainly be used to help
the state pension system.
Seventh,
according to my union, the Illinois Federation of Teachers, representatives of
the two teachers’ unions were only invited to four of the meetings of your
pension committee. This seems
grossly unfair. According to the
IFT, representatives of the Civic Committee of the Commercial Club of Chicago
were invited to ALL of the pension meetings.
Governor,
I hope you will stop and consider other solutions to the pension problem. Making active Illinois teachers and
school districts bear total burden of reform is unfair. Others must participate as well.
Thank
you for reading my letter.
Sincerely,
James
G. Wyman
Thank you, sir. Impeccably said.
ReplyDeleteWell written and very clearly stated!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comments. Bob Haisman has a petition to sign protesting the governor's pension form. Here's the link.
ReplyDeletehttp://signon.org/sign/governor-quinn-leave?source=s.em.cr&r_by=1424651&mailing_id=3617
Teachers need to go on offense.
ReplyDeleteTell the State to sell land, buildings and Lake Michigan water.